/

January 21, 2025

How to Handle Online Reviews as a Law Firm

Responding to Negatives and Leveraging Positives

For law firms, reputation is everything. While legal expertise and client service are critical, many potential clients will form an opinion about your firm long before they step into your office. Where do they look? Online reviews.

Online reviews influence consumer trust, and for a service-based industry like legal services, they can make or break your firm’s ability to attract new clients. 85% of people trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, and legal services are no exception.

This guide will help your firm:

  1. Respond professionally to negative reviews.
  2. Leverage positive reviews to attract clients.
  3. Encourage more reviews without breaking ethical guidelines.

Let’s dive in.

1. Why Online Reviews Matter for Law Firms

Online reviews can impact your law firm in the following ways:

1.1 Increase Client Trust

  • Positive reviews act as social proof, reassuring potential clients that your firm can deliver results.
  • A mix of genuine positive and negative reviews shows authenticity (people often distrust “perfect” ratings).

1.2 Improve Local SEO

  • Reviews on platforms like Google My Business (GMB), Yelp, and Avvo influence your local search rankings. The more positive, recent reviews you have, the more likely your firm will appear at the top of searches like “personal injury lawyer near me.”

1.3 Drive Client Decisions

  • Clients often compare law firms based on reviews before reaching out. A few bad reviews left unaddressed can push potential clients toward competitors.

2. How to Respond to Negative Reviews

Negative reviews are inevitable, even for the best law firms. What matters is how you handle them. Responding appropriately can protect—and even enhance—your reputation.

2.1 Stay Calm and Professional

  • Avoid the temptation to argue or defend yourself emotionally.
  • A calm, measured response shows you’re professional and client-focused.

2.2 Acknowledge the Client’s Experience

  • Show empathy by acknowledging their concerns, even if you disagree with their interpretation.
  • Example Response:
    • “Thank you for your feedback, [Name]. We’re sorry to hear that your experience didn’t meet your expectations. Your concerns are important to us, and we’d like to understand more about what happened.”

2.3 Keep It General to Protect Confidentiality

  • Avoid sharing client-specific details in your response to comply with attorney-client privilege and ethical guidelines.
  • Example: Instead of saying, “You didn’t provide all the required documents on time,” write:
    • “We always strive to meet our clients’ needs, and we apologize if there was any miscommunication during the process.”

2.4 Offer to Take the Conversation Offline

  • Resolve the issue privately by providing contact information.
  • Example Response:
    • “We’d like to make things right. Please contact us directly at [email/phone] so we can discuss this further.”

2.5 Avoid Fake or Generic Apologies

  • A cookie-cutter response won’t feel authentic. Tailor your message to each reviewer’s concerns.

Pro Tip: Respond promptly. The quicker you address a negative review, the more likely the client is to feel heard and possibly amend their review later.

3. How to Leverage Positive Reviews

Positive reviews are your law firm’s greatest asset. Here’s how to amplify their impact:

3.1 Highlight Reviews on Your Website

  • Use client testimonials from Google, Avvo, or Yelp on your homepage, landing pages, and service pages.
  • Example:
    • “XYZ Law Firm guided me through my case with professionalism and care. I highly recommend them!”

3.2 Share Reviews on Social Media

  • Post positive reviews on your firm’s LinkedIn, Facebook, or Instagram accounts. Add a brief note to provide context:
    • “We’re honored to have helped [Name] achieve this outcome. Here’s what they had to say!”

3.3 Build Trust with Prospective Clients

  • Share reviews during consultations or follow-ups to reinforce credibility. For example:
    • “Here’s a case similar to yours that we handled successfully—our client had this to say about their experience.”

3.4 Use Reviews to Motivate Your Team

  • Share positive client feedback internally to recognize and encourage your team’s hard work.

Pro Tip: Highlight specific outcomes in reviews. Potential clients are often drawn to success stories, such as winning settlements, resolving disputes, or creating comprehensive estate plans.

4. How to Encourage More Reviews Ethically

It’s important to have a steady flow of new reviews, as clients value recent feedback. However, law firms must follow ethical guidelines to avoid misleading practices.

4.1 When to Ask for Reviews

  • After a Case Is Resolved: If a client expresses satisfaction, ask them for a review.
  • At Key Milestones: For ongoing cases, ask for reviews when clients hit important milestones (e.g., signing an estate plan).

4.2 How to Ask for Reviews

  • Be Direct but Polite:
    • Example:
      • “We hope you were satisfied with our services. If so, we’d greatly appreciate it if you could leave us a Google review. Your feedback helps other clients find us!”
  • Provide Instructions:
    • Include a direct link to your Google or Yelp review page.

4.3 Avoid Offering Incentives

  • Offering discounts or gifts in exchange for reviews is unethical and can result in penalties from platforms like Google.

4.4 Use Email Campaigns

  • Send follow-up emails with a review request.
    • Example Email Template:
      • Subject Line: How Was Your Experience with Us?
      • Body: “Thank you for trusting us with your legal needs. We value your feedback and would love to hear about your experience. Please take a moment to leave us a review here: [Insert link].”

Pro Tip: Remind clients that their reviews help others facing similar legal challenges find reliable guidance.

5. Tools for Managing Online Reviews

Streamline the process of monitoring and responding to reviews with these tools:

  1. Google My Business Dashboard:
    • Monitor reviews and respond directly from your GMB profile.
  2. Reputation Management Software:
    • Tools like Birdeye, Podium, or Trustpilot allow you to track reviews across multiple platforms.
  3. Alerts and Notifications:
    • Set up email alerts for new reviews so you can respond promptly.
  4. Analytics Tools:
    • Use tools like BrightLocal or Yext to track review trends and measure their impact on your SEO rankings.

6. Best Practices for Managing Reviews

To maintain a stellar reputation online:

  • Respond Promptly: A quick response shows that your firm values feedback.
  • Stay Consistent: Respond to all reviews, positive or negative, to build trust.
  • Avoid Fake Reviews: Never generate fake reviews, as platforms like Google can penalize your listing.
  • Engage with Clients Post-Review: Thank reviewers privately or publicly to foster loyalty.

Turning Reviews Into Your Competitive Advantage

Online reviews are more than just feedback—they’re a powerful tool for building your law firm’s reputation, improving local SEO, and converting potential leads into clients.

By responding to negative reviews professionally, amplifying positive reviews, and encouraging satisfied clients to share their experiences, you can take control of your firm’s online presence.

Start managing your reviews today, and you’ll see how even small improvements can translate into more trust, more clients, and more growth for your firm.

FAQs: How to Handle Online Reviews as a Law Firm

Q1: Why are online reviews so important for law firms?

Online reviews are crucial for law firms because they directly impact client trust and decision-making. Research shows that 85% of people trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Reviews also influence your local SEO rankings, helping potential clients find your firm when searching for legal services in their area. Positive reviews serve as social proof of your firm’s expertise and reliability.

Q2: How should I respond to a negative review while maintaining client confidentiality?

When responding to negative reviews, keep your response general and avoid sharing any specific case details to protect attorney-client privilege. Focus on acknowledging the reviewer’s concerns without discussing confidential information. For example, instead of addressing specific case details, say something like: “We’re sorry to hear about your experience. We take client feedback seriously and would appreciate the opportunity to discuss your concerns privately. Please contact our office at [contact information].”

Q3: Is it ethical to ask clients for reviews?

Yes, it’s ethical to ask clients for reviews as long as you follow proper guidelines. You can request reviews after a case is resolved or at key milestones, but you must never offer incentives or rewards in exchange for reviews. The request should be straightforward and optional, without any pressure or implied benefits.

Q4: When is the best time to ask clients for reviews?

The optimal times to request reviews are:

  • After successfully resolving a case
  • Following the completion of key milestones in ongoing cases
  • When clients express satisfaction with your services
  • During natural follow-up communications after service completion

Q5: What should I do if a client posts confidential case information in their review?

While you cannot control what a client posts, you should never confirm or deny confidential information in your response. Instead, respond with a general acknowledgment and invite them to discuss their concerns privately: “Thank you for your feedback. To protect client confidentiality, we’d like to address your specific concerns directly. Please contact our office to discuss this matter further.”

Q6: How quickly should I respond to online reviews?

You should aim to respond to reviews as promptly as possible, ideally within 24-48 hours. Quick responses show that your firm values client feedback and is actively engaged in maintaining its online reputation. This is especially important for negative reviews, as a swift response can help mitigate potential damage and show other potential clients that you take concerns seriously.

Q7: Can I use review management software for my law firm?

Yes, you can use review management software like Birdeye, Podium, or Trustpilot to help monitor and manage reviews across multiple platforms. These tools can help you track reviews, set up alerts for new feedback, and analyze trends in your reviews. However, ensure that any automated responses are customized to maintain a personal touch.

Q8: How can I leverage positive reviews to attract more clients?

You can maximize the impact of positive reviews by:

  • Featuring them prominently on your website
  • Sharing them on social media platforms
  • Including them in consultation materials
  • Using them in marketing materials (with proper permission)
  • Highlighting specific successful outcomes that potential clients can relate to

Q9: What should I do about fake negative reviews?

If you suspect a review is fake or from someone who was never a client, follow these steps:

  1. Document the review and any evidence showing it’s fraudulent
  2. Report it to the platform (Google, Yelp, etc.) using their official dispute process
  3. Respond professionally, stating that you have no record of this person as a client
  4. Never engage in arguments or accusations in public responses

Q10: How many reviews should my law firm aim to have?

There’s no specific number of reviews your firm should target, but you should focus on maintaining a steady flow of recent, authentic reviews. What matters most is the quality and recency of reviews rather than quantity. Having a mix of positive and a few negative reviews (with professional responses) can actually increase credibility, as potential clients often distrust perfect 5-star ratings.

author avatar
YMM Digital
See Full Bio

From the same category